Mispunish

Multiple punitive damages are likely to mispunish defendants.

Source: wiktionary

Some people do not correctly apply the natural law, or they tend to be biased when judging in their own cases, or they tend to mispunish, overpunish, etc.

Source: wiktionary

Ordinarily, hate censorship theorists would be the first to distrust a law that could so mispunish – but this is not the case when it comes to hate speech law.

Source: wiktionary

But what is a guilty person's complaint against an unreliable procedure? That it is too likely to mispunish him?

Source: wiktionary