Incredulity

The lover listened with obstinate incredulity.

An appeal to common sense is a type of argument from incredulity, a logical fallacy.

Wide went her eyes in wonder and incredulity, as she beheld this seeming apparition risen from the dead.

It was a casual sneer, obviously one of a long line. There was hatred behind it, but of a quiet, chronic type, nothing new or unduly virulent, and he was taken aback by the flicker of amazed incredulity that passed over the younger man's ravaged face.

At any other time Jessamy would have laughed at the expressions that chased each other over his freckled face: crossness left over from his struggle with the baby; incredulity; distress; and finally delight.